Exploring the Categorization of Elden Ring: A Debate on Soulslike Games


The debate over whether Elden Ring can be classified as a Soulslike game has sparked discussion within the gaming community. The roots of the Soulslike genre can be traced back to games like Demon Souls and Dark Souls, which introduced players to a unique blend of dark aesthetics and challenging gameplay. These games, characterized by their gritty storytelling and brutal combat mechanics, have inspired a wave of similar titles seeking to capture the essence of the Souls series.

As the popularity of Soulslike games has grown, so too has the debate over what defines a game as Soulslike. While some argue that Elden Ring, developed by the same minds behind the Souls series, should be considered a Soulslike game due to its thematic and gameplay similarities, others believe that it deserves a category of its own.

Drawing parallels to the Metroidvania genre, which pays homage to games like Super Metroid, the discussion extends to whether newer titles like Elden Ring should be placed in the same category as their predecessors. The allure of games developed by certain studios, such as FromSoft, creates a unique gaming experience that transcends traditional genre classifications, much like how Pokemon and Mario games have established their distinct identities in the gaming world.

Ultimately, the question remains: is Elden Ring a Soulslike game, or does it warrant its own classification? The answer may lie in the subjective interpretation of players and the evolving landscape of gaming genres. Whether Elden Ring is viewed as a continuation of the Souls legacy or a standalone masterpiece, one thing is certain – its impact on the gaming industry is undeniable.